Evaluating College Options

For most families, the “right” division is the one that matches your teen’s level, priorities, and budget—not the highest logo they can chase. Evaluating DI vs DII vs DIII works best when you compare them on a few concrete dimensions rather than reputation alone.

Start with your teen’s priorities

Before looking at divisions, clarify what your player actually wants out of college soccer.

How important are playing time, conference prestige, and the possibility (even if small) of turning pro.
How demanding an athletic schedule can they realistically handle alongside their academics and social life.
How much financial help does your family need, and are you open to merit and need‑based aid, not just athletic money.

Writing these out first makes it easier to see which division profiles align with your teen’s real goals instead of social pressure or myths about DI.

Key differences at a glance

Use this table as a working tool; the exact experience varies a lot by specific school and program.

Factor	Division I	Division II	Division III
Typical level of play	Highest overall; most roster depth and athleticism.	Strong, especially at nationally ranked programs; overlaps with lower–mid D1.	Very wide range; top D3 can match solid D2/low‑D1, but many programs are more developmental.
Time demand	Often feels like a full‑time job in season, with year‑round expectations.	Serious commitment but usually slightly more balanced than D1.	Generally more flexible; more room for academics, work, and other activities (though top D3s can be intense).
Athletic scholarships	Yes; mostly partial awards, with tight competition for meaningful money.	Yes; partial equivalency aid, often stacked with academic packages.	No athletic aid; financial help is academic and need‑based.
Academic emphasis	Varies widely by school and conference.	Mixed; often solid regional universities.	Often strongest academic focus; many small or medium selective colleges.
Pathway to pro	Highest baseline odds; many MLS/NWSL players come from D1.	Some pro placements, especially via top programs and summer leagues.	Fewer overall, but outliers do reach pro levels from top D3s.

Matching your teen to the right level

Once you understand the broad differences, evaluate where your teen realistically fits today—and where they could be in 2–3 years.

On‑field profile: Compare your teen’s impact at club level (ECNL, GA, MLS NEXT, strong regional leagues or equivalent) to known commits at schools they like; D1 commits typically dominate strong environments and show advanced physical and tactical tools.
Academic profile: Strong grades and test scores widen options at every division and are especially valuable at D3 and academically selective D1/D2 schools that lean heavily on merit and need‑based aid. One thing about soccer is that unlike football and basketball, strong college soccer programs are often found at schools where the overall academic bar is relatively high, and that many top soccer players are genuinely strong students eg; Ivies.
Lifestyle tolerance: Some players thrive in D1’s heavy travel and training load, while others would be happier in a strong D2 or top D3 setting that leaves room for internships, studying abroad, or double majors.

If your teen is a fringe D1 prospect on soccer alone but has excellent academics, a top D3 or strong D2 might deliver better minutes on the field and a better long‑term degree. Conversely, a player with clear high‑end athletic upside who lives for the grind may be willing to accept less academic flexibility for a realistic D1 opportunity.

Practical steps to compare real programs

Divisions are helpful labels, but real evaluation happens program by program.

Build a shortlist in each division (for example, 5–8 D1, 10–12 D2, 10–12 D3) that fit your teen’s academics, position, and geography, then research how many players in their spot actually play meaningful minutes.
Ask coaches specific questions on calls/visits about time demands, roster size, redshirting, transfer patterns, and how many players on the roster receive athletic vs. academic money.
Where possible, watch full‑match film or attend games; seeing the speed, physicality, and decision‑making level is far more useful than relying on highlight videos or division labels alone.

As your family gathers this information, patterns will emerge: certain divisions and program types will consistently line up better with your teen’s reality and preferences. That is usually your signal to lean into those lanes rather than forcing a fit at a level that looks good on paper but would be a daily struggle in practice.

Evaluating College Options

Start with your teen’s priorities

Key differences at a glance

Matching your teen to the right level

Practical steps to compare real programs

Other Interesting Content

Stay Ahead of the Game ⚽